ASSESSMENT OF ACUTE POISONING AMONG CHILDREN IN DAMIETTA GOVERNORATE

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Departments of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology, Al-Azhar Faculty of Medicine

2 Departments of Anesthesia and Intensive care, Al-Azhar Faculty of Medicine

3 Departments of Clinical Pathology, Al-Azhar Faculty of Medicine

4 Departments of Radiology, Al-Azhar Faculty of Medicine

Abstract

Background: Unintentional toxicology represented an important health problem in pediatrics. However, there was no appropriate map helping in design of proper preventive strategies.
Objective: Investigating the pattern of acute toxicity of children aged 1–18 years in Damietta governorate.
Subjects and methods: The study included children presented to Emergency Department of Damietta Poison Control Center (PCC) during the period from January 2015 to December 2015. In all children, the following parameters were studied: mean age, sex, residence, occupation, route of exposure, manner of poisoning, time elapsed between exposure to toxin and hospital arrival, past medical history, family history, seasonal distribution, admission place (ED, inpatient, ICU, or referral); and outcome (Improvement, referral and death). Clinical and Investigational aspect of the study included general examination, systemic examination and investigations (laboratory, ECG, Plain chest X-ray, Plain abdominal X-ray, CT and/or MRI in cases of coma or unexplained etiology). Curative aspect of the study included emergency measures, decontamination, enhancement of elimination, and administration of specific therapy).
Results: There was a statistically significant difference between studied groups as regard gender distribution. Residence was rural in 78.4% and urban in 21.6%. The most common toxic agent(s) were insecticides (46.6%), hydrocarbons (24.1%), corrosives (19.8%) and medicinal agents (9.5%).  The toxicity was mild in majority of children (72.4%), and the severity of toxicity increased with increasing age. The delay time was less than an hour in the majority of children (58.6%). The oral route was the most common (69.0%) and oral route intoxication increased with increasing age.  Intoxication was accidental in the majority of studied children (84.5%) and no suicidal cases below the age of 6 years. Location of toxicity in studied children was home in the majority of subjects (84.5%) and outside home (15.5%), with a statistically significant difference between them. Outcome revealed that 30.2% and 69.8% were discharged from Emergency Department. The discharge rate from Emergency Department decreased with increasing age.
Conclusion: The present study provided a road map for the pattern of childhood toxicity in Dameitta governorate. It is the first step to explore the magnitude of the problem in this area of Egypt. Future efforts are needed to complete the map with development of effective preventive strategies. 

Keywords


ASSESSMENT OF ACUTE POISONING AMONG CHILDREN IN DAMIETTA GOVERNORATE

 

By

 

Ahmed I.A Elshoura*, Magdy M. Sherif*, Tawfik M. Noor El-Deen**, Mekky A. Ali***, Mohamed A. Abbod****, and Mostafa A. Ghanem*

 

Departments of Forensic Medicine and Clinical Toxicology*, Anesthesia and Intensive care**,

Clinical Pathology***, and Radiology****, Al-Azhar Faculty of Medicine

 

ABSTRACT

Background: Unintentional toxicology represented an important health problem in pediatrics. However, there was no appropriate map helping in design of proper preventive strategies.

Objective: Investigating the pattern of acute toxicity of children aged 1–18 years in Damietta governorate.

Subjects and methods: The study included children presented to Emergency Department of Damietta Poison Control Center (PCC) during the period from January 2015 to December 2015. In all children, the following parameters were studied: mean age, sex, residence, occupation, route of exposure, manner of poisoning, time elapsed between exposure to toxin and hospital arrival, past medical history, family history, seasonal distribution, admission place (ED, inpatient, ICU, or referral); and outcome (Improvement, referral and death). Clinical and Investigational aspect of the study included general examination, systemic examination and investigations (laboratory, ECG, Plain chest X-ray, Plain abdominal X-ray, CT and/or MRI in cases of coma or unexplained etiology). Curative aspect of the study included emergency measures, decontamination, enhancement of elimination, and administration of specific therapy).

Results: There was a statistically significant difference between studied groups as regard gender distribution. Residence was rural in 78.4% and urban in 21.6%. The most common toxic agent(s) were insecticides (46.6%), hydrocarbons (24.1%), corrosives (19.8%) and medicinal agents (9.5%).  The toxicity was mild in majority of children (72.4%), and the severity of toxicity increased with increasing age. The delay time was less than an hour in the majority of children (58.6%). The oral route was the most common (69.0%) and oral route intoxication increased with increasing age.  Intoxication was accidental in the majority of studied children (84.5%) and no suicidal cases below the age of 6 years. Location of toxicity in studied children was home in the majority of subjects (84.5%) and outside home (15.5%), with a statistically significant difference between them. Outcome revealed that 30.2% and 69.8% were discharged from Emergency Department. The discharge rate from Emergency Department decreased with increasing age.

Conclusion: The present study provided a road map for the pattern of childhood toxicity in Dameitta governorate. It is the first step to explore the magnitude of the problem in this area of Egypt. Future efforts are needed to complete the map with development of effective preventive strategies. 

Keywords: Child, poisoning, insecticides, accidental.

 

 

INTRODUCTION

     Poisoning can cause injury or death due to a toxic substance. The extent of injury depends on the amount of the poisonous material, the extent of absorption and distribution, and the innate power of the poison (Kivistö et al.,
2008-a).

     Toxic compounds may be ingested or inhaled either accidentally or deliberately. Accidental poisoning can occur at any age, but is much more common in children. Peak incidence is around the age of 2 years, and boys are at more risk than girls. Most incidents (80–85%) occur in the child’s home and, in many cases, the substances involved have not been stored in their usual place or have been put into a different container (Torgerson et al., 2015). Household products are more commonly ingested than drugs by children and seasonal variability has been described. Pesticides and weed killers are more commonly ingested in spring, berry poisoning occurs in autumn, and cough and cold remedies are more commonly ingested in winter. Deliberate poisoning is more common in adults, but is increasing in the teenage population. The incidence of analgesic ingestion has particularly increased. Depression and deliberate self-harm are often found concurrently with analgesic overdose, and the particular needs of this population differs from adults. Poisoning accounts for a very small proportion of deaths in children under 10 years of age. This declining proportion of deaths in children may be attributable to the widespread introduction of child-resistant closures on containers. However, other factors, including greater emphasis on safety in the home, improved access to information on poisons and improved treatment may also contribute to reducing mortality (Riordan et al., 2002).

     The aim of this study was to assess the problem of acute toxicity among children in Damietta Governorate.

SUBJECTSAND METHODS

    This study was conducted on cases of acute toxicity between children of both sexes, and different ages from age of one year to age of eighteen years old, referred to Damietta Poison Control Center, during the period from January 2015 to December 2015.

    Assessment of the acute toxicity was based on history of exposure to the toxin, time elapsed between exposure and referral, any treatment received, and history of previous or present illness. Clinical picture included different symptoms and signs of the particular poisonous substance involving the specific manifestations of each toxin, i.e. the toxidrome, and specific toxicological analysis whenever available.

    In all children, the following parameters were studied: mean age, sex, residence, occupation if present, route of exposure, manner of poisoning, time elapsed between exposure to toxin and hospital arrival, past medical history, family history, seasonal distribution, admission place (emergency medicine department, inpatient, intensive care unit, or referral), and outcome (Improvement, referral and death). Clinical and investigational aspects of the study included general examination, systemic examination, and investigations (laboratory, ECG, plain chest X-ray; plain abdominal X-ray; and CT and/or MRI in cases of coma or unexplained etiology). Curative aspects of the study included emergency measures, decontamination, enhancement of elimina-tion, and administration of specific therapy.

Statistical analysis: The collected data were organized, tabulated and statistically analyzed using both Microsoft office excel 2010 (Microsoft®; USA) and statistical package for social science version 20, running on IBM-compatible computer. Chi square (X2) was used for comparison between groups for qualitative data. P value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

     The present study included 116 children; 40 of them (34.5%) were in group 1 (from 1 to 3 years); 20 (17.2%) in group 2 (4-6 years); 19 (16.4%) in group 3 (7-12 years), and finally 37 children (31.9%) in group 4 (13-18 years). These data revealed that the higher incidence of intoxication were in first and 4th groups respectively). Males were 49 children, representing 42.2% of studied children; while females were 67 children (57.8%). There was a statistically significant difference between studied groups as regards gender distribution (males represented 30.0%, 20.0%, 36.8% and 37.8% of groups 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively). Residence was rural in 91 children (78.4%) and urban in 24 children (21.6%); with insignificant difference between studied groups (Table 1).

     The most common toxic agent were insecticides (54 children; 46.6%); hydrocarbons in 28 children (24.1%); corrosives (23 children; 19.8%) and medicinal agents (11 children; 9.5%). There was statistically no significant difference between the studied groups (Table 2).

    The higher incidence of intoxication was in May (22 children; 19.0%), then August (19 children; 16.4%), followed by March (12 children; 10.3%), and there was statistically non-significant difference between studied groups.

    The severity of poisoning was mild in majority of children (72.4%), moderate in 32 children (27.6%). There was a statistically significant increase of mild toxicity in groups 1 and 2 (85.0, 80.0% respectively) when compared to groups 3 and 4 (73.7% and 54.1% respectively). The severity of toxicity increased with increasing age. The delay time between intoxication and arrival to emergency department was less than an hour in the majority of children (68; 58.6%), 1 – 6 hours in 43 children (37.1%), more than 6 hours in 3 children (2.6%), and unknown in 2 children (1.7%), with non-significant difference between studied groups. The major route of exposure was the oral route (80 children; 69.0%). Other routes (e.g., skin and respiratory) were in 36 children (31.0%) with a statistically significant increase of oral route in groups 4 & 3 (89.2% & 78.9% respectively) when compared to groups 2 and 1 (65.0% & 47.5% respectively) (Table 2).

   The mode of intoxication was accidental in the majority of studied children (98 children; 84.5%), and suicidal in 18 children (15.5%). There was statistically significant increase of accidental routes in groups 1, 2 and 3 (100.0%, 100.0% and 94.7% respectively) when compared to group 4 (54.1%). These results indicated that, below the age of 6 years, no suicidal cases; while in group 7 to 12 years; there was only one child with suicidal attempt and last 17 suicidal attempts were in group 13 to 18 years.  No case occurred in the present work. The location of toxicity in studied children was home in the majority of subjects (98 patients; 84.5%), and outside home in 18 subjects (15.5%). There was statistically significant differences between studied groups as regard to location of toxicity (home in 100.0%, 85.0%, 68.4% and 75.7% in groups 1, 2 3 and 4 respectively) (Table 2).

    Thirty five children (30.2%) and 81 children (69.8%) were discharged from Emergency Department with a statistically significant difference between studied groups. The discharge rate from emergency department decreased with increasing age (87.5%, 75.0%, 68.4% and 48.6% in groups 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively) (Table 3).

    Diabetes mellitus was reported in 1 child (0.9%), 6 children (5.2%) had positive past history of renal disease; 7 (6.0%) with liver disease; 5 (4.3%) with heart disease, 14 children had positive past history of surgery; 8(6.9%) positive for blood transfusion, and 53 children (45.7%) had past history of drug therapy, 4 children (3.4%) had positive family history for familial disease, and 29 children (25.0%) had positive family history for psychosocial troubles. There was statistically significant difference between studied group as regards past history of surgery and blood transfusion and for family history of psychosocial troubles (Table 4).

    High percentage of studied children had normal consciousness (72.4%), while 27.6% were drowsy. The pupil was normal in 68.1% of children and constricted in 31.9%. Heart rate was normal in 75% of children and abnormal in 25.0%. Blood pressure was normal for age and sex in 69.8%, and abnormal in 30.2%. Temperature was normal in 65.5%, and abnormal in 34.5%. Respiratory rate was normal in 75%, and abnormal in 25%. There was no significant difference between studied groups as regards any of studied variables except for consciousness; where drowsiness significantly increased with increased age (Table 5).

 

 

Table (1): Distribution of studied children as regard to age group

Groups

Parameters 

Group 1

 (1-3 y)

Group 2

(4-6 y)

Group 3

 (7-12y)

Group 4

(13-18y)

X2

P value

No,%

40

(34.5%)

20

(17.2%)

19

(16.4%)

37

(31.9%)

-

-

Sex

Male

24(60.0%)

4(20.0%)

7(36.8%)

14(37.8%)

9.74

0.021

Female

16(40.0%)

16(80.0%)

12(63.2%)

23(62.2%)

Residence

Rural

34(85.0%)

17(85.0%)

16(84.2%)

24(64.9%)

5.93

0.12

 

Urban

6(15.0%)

3(15.0%)

3(15.8%)

13(35.1%)

y=year

 

 

Table (2): Characteristics of intoxication in studied children.

Groups

Parameters

Group 1

 (1-3 y)

Group 2

(4-6 Y)

Group 3

 (7-12y)

Group 4

(13-18y)

X2

P value

Toxic agent

Insecticide

23(57.5%)

6(30.0%)

8(42.1%)

17(45.9%)

 

8.78

 

0.45

 

Hydrocarbon

10(25.0%)

7(35.0%)

4(21.1%)

7(18.9%)

Corrosives

6(15.0%)

5(25.0%)

5(26.3%)

7(18.9%)

Drugs

1(2.5%)

2(10.0%)

2(10.5%)

6(16.2%)

Severity

Mild

34(85.0%)

16(80.0%)

14(73.7%)

20(54.1%)

10.0

0.019

Moderate

6(15.0%)

4(20.0%)

5(26.3%)

17(45.9%)

Delay

Time

(hours)

<1

27(67.5%)

12(60.0%)

13(68.4%)

16(43.2%)

 

11.10

 

0.27

 

1-6

13(32.5%)

8(40.0%)

4(21.1%)

18(48.6%)

>6

0(0.0%)

0(0.0%)

1(5.3%)

2(5.4%)

Unknown

0(0.0%)

0(0.0%)

1(5.3%)

1(2.7%)

Route of

Exposure

Oral

19(47.5%)

13(65.0%)

15(78.9%)

33(89.2%)

16.71

0.001

Other

21(52.5%)

7(35.0%)

4(21.1%)

4(10.8%)

Mode of poisoning

Accidental

40(100%)

20(100%)

18(94.7%)

20(54.1%)

38.67

0.001

Suicidal

0(0.0%)

0(0.0%)

1(5.3%)

17(45.9%)

Poisoning

Location

Home

40(100%)

17(85.0%)

13(68.4%)

28(75.7%)

13.27

0.004

Outside home

0(0.0%)

3(15.0%)

6(31.6%)

9(24.3%)

y=year

 

Table (3): Hospital admission in studied children.

Groups

 

Parameters

Group 1

(1-3 y)

Group 2

(4-6 y)

Group 3

 (7-12y)

Group 4

 (13-18y)

Total

N

%

N

%

N

%

n

%

n

%

Hospital

Admission

5

12.5

5

25.0

6

31.6

19

51.4

35

30.2

Discharge

From Emergency Department

35

87.5

15

75.0

13

68.4

18

48.6

81

69.8

X2= 14.07, p = 0.003*


n= number of cases, y=years

 

Table (4): Past and family history in studied children

              Groups

 

Parameters

Group 1

(1-3 y)

Group 2

(4-6 Y)

Group 3

(7-12y)

Group 4

(13-18y)

Total

P

n

%

n

%

n

%

n

%

n

%

Past history

DM

0

0

0

0

0

0.0

1

2.7

1

.9

0.54

HTN

0

0

0

0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

-

RD

2

5

0

0

3

15.8

1

2.7

6

5.2

0.12

LD

0

0

2

10

1

5.3

4

10.8

7

6.0

0.20

HD

2

5

1

5

1

5.3

1

2.7

5

4.3

0.95

Surgery

0

0

2

10

5

26.3

7

18.9

14

12.1

0.013

BT

1

2.5

4

20

3

15.8

0

0.0

8

6.9

0.009

Dr. th.

16

40

9

45

10

52.6

18

48.6

53

45.7

0.79

Family history

FD

2

5

1

5

1

5.3

0

0.0

4

3.4

0.58

PsT

6

15

2

10

1

5.3

20

54.1

29

25.0

<0.001

DM= diabetes mellitus; HTN= hypertension; RD: renal disease; LD: liver disease; HD= heart disease; BT: blood transfusion; Dr. th. = drug therapy; FD: familial disease; Pst: psychosocial troubles. n= number of cases, y=years

 

 

Table (5): Clinical examination in studied children.

Groups

 

Parameters

Group 1

(1-3 y)

Group 2

(4-6 Y)

Group 3

(7-12y)

Group 4

(13-18y)

Total

P

N

%

n

%

N

%

n

%

n

%

Conscious-ness

Normal

34

85

16

80

14

73.7

20

54.1

84

72.4

0.019

Drowsy

6

15

4

20

5

26.3

17

45.9

32

27.6

Pupil

Normal

22

55

17

85

15

78.9

25

67.6

79

68.1

0.08

Constricted

18

45

3

15

4

21.1

12

32.4

37

31.9

HR

Normal

28

70

14

70

16

84.2

29

78.4

87

75

0.60

abnormal 

12

30

6

30

3

15.8

8

21.6

29

25

BP

Normal

23

57.5

17

85

15

78.9

26

70.3

81

69.8

0.12

abnormal 

17

42.5

3

15

4

21.1

11

29.7

35

30.2

Temp.

Normal

22

55

13

65

15

78.9

26

70.3

76

65.5

0.27

abnormal 

18

45

7

35

4

21.1

11

29.7

40

34.5

RR

Normal

28

70

14

70

16

84.2

29

78.4

87

75

0.59

abnormal 

12

30

6

30

3

15.8

8

21.6

29

25

 


DISCUSSION

     Poisoning is the third most common emergency of pediatrics leading to high social and economic burden. The high prevalence of acute poisoning in children is attributed to the curiosity of the children especially those aged less than 5 years to virtually taste or swallow harmful substances (Rodgers et al., 2007). The prevalence and types of poisoning vary considerably across the world and depend on socioeconomic status and cultural practices, as well as on local industrial and agricultural activities (Peden et al., 2008).  Acute poisoning represents one of the most common medical emergencies in childhood. Determination of epidemio-logical characters of childhood poisoning is of paramount importance for preventive measures and treatment plane (Hassan and Siam, 2014).

     The present study was designed to investigate the pattern of acute toxicity of children aged 1–18 years in Damietta governorate. Children belonging to age group of 1–6 years represented the largest proportion (51.7%); (34.5%) of them were in group 1 (from 1 to 3 years), and 17.2% were in group 2 (4-6 years), (16.4%) were in group  (7-12 years), and finally children (31.9%) were in group 13-18 years. These results were in agreement with Lamireau et al. (2002) study. Also, several studies in Turkey reported that 51–73% of all poisoning cases were observed in children of 5 years of age (Andiran and Sarikayalar, 2004; Bicer et al., 2007; Ozdogan et al., 2008 and Mutlu et al., 2010).  In addition, in USA, it was reported that peak poison exposure incidence was noted in 1- and 2-year-old children. Children younger than 4 years comprised 46% of all poison exposures reported to US poison centers (Litovitz et al., 2005).  The age distribution seems to be peak at two points i.e. with most poisonings occurring in children aged between one and 4 years, and then again in teenagers over the age of 14 (Kivisto et al., 2008-b).  

     In the present study, there was male predominance in the first group (aged 1 – 3 years), while, in the subsequent groups, there was female predominance. Generally, there was slight increase of females when compared to males (57.8% vs 42.2% respectively).  These results contradicted with those reported by Lin et al. (2003) that there was male predominance of toxicity in their studied children. This study could be due to that, in some cultures, girls are expected not to engage in outdoor activities or to adopt risk-taking behavior. Aggarwal et al. (2014) reported a relatively higher proportion of boys than girls which was sustained across the all age groups. Male dominance could be due to their  aggressive and exploratory nature, relatively more freedom in society, higher level of stress partially due to expectation and social responsibilities in family, and referral bias towards boys for hospitalization over girls (Rajapakse et al., 2013 and Singh et al., 2013).

     In the present study, residence was rural in 78.4% of children, and urban in 21.6% of children, with a statistically non-significant difference between the studied groups. These results were comparable to those reported by Hassan and Siam (2014) that the number of poisoned children was higher in rural areas than that of urban areas. Also, O’Connor (2005) stated that children poisoning admission rates have been consistently higher in rural areas than urban areas. This was probably due to, in urban areas many cases are treated in private hospitals (Hassan and Siam, 2014).

     Agran et al. (2001) reported that poisoning of children up to the age of 10 years tends to be unintentional. In addition, these results were consistent with other results from Islamic countries. The low incidence of suicide could be associated with the strict forbiddance of suicide by Islam and the religious practice of the majority of the populations (Mutlu et al., 2010).

     Hon and Colleagues (2005) alsonoted that most of these admissions involved unintentional poisoning. Compared with unintentional poisoning, patients who intentionally poisoned themselves were significantly older and were predominantly females. Furthermore, these results were in accordance with Litovitz et al. (2005) who reported that exposure reasons are presented by age group showing that unintentional general exposures predominate in younger children, comprising 91% of exposures in children younger than 6 years. These unintentional general exposures are unforeseen, unplanned events in children or adults without the ability to realize the danger of their actions. Also, results of the present study were in agreement with Aggarwal et al. (2014) who reported that it is unfortunate to see an increase in suicidal poisoning in adolescents probably related to the stress related to academic performance, peers, family, and social life.

Severity of intoxication was mild in majority of children (72.4%), and moderate in 27.6%. There were statistically significant increases of mild toxicity in groups 1 and 2 when compared to groups 3 and 4. These results indicated the severity of toxicity increased with increasing age. These results were in agreement with Rajka et al. (2007) who reported that most of the poisonings in their study were mild; and there was proportional correlation between severity of intoxication and age.

    Delay time between intoxication and arrival to emergency department was less than an hour in the majority of children,
1 – 6 hours in 37.1%, more than 6 hours in 2.6%, and unknown in 1.7%, with a statistically non-significant difference between studied groups.  These results were comparable to those reported by Aggarwal et al. (2014) who reported that 42% of patients presented within one hour of ingestion. However, it was observed that majority of the patients who reported early belonged to urban regions.

     Location of toxicity in studied children was home in the majority of subjects (84.5%) and outside home in (15.5%), with a statistically significant difference. These results were in agreement with Mendonca et al. (2016) who reported that cases of intoxication in children less than 4 years of age were the most frequent, and the accidents occurred in the home.  In addition, it had been reported that the domestic environment is the place where the child remains the greater part of the time, and is also the place with the highest number of accidents involving poisoning in the first 5 years of life (Tavares et al., 2013).  Siqueira et al. (2008) also repor-ted that 80.2% of poisonings occurred in the home. Bentur et al. (2010) related that, in 89.3% of cases, the residence was the place of occurrence; however.

     The toxic agents found in the home, without adequate storage, may be transformed into a risk of accidents, as observed in a study in Spain (Azkunaga et al., 2013). In Brazil, Lourenco et al. (2008) observed that 81% of the accidents occur in the residence, with 65.4% involving 5-yearold children, and the parents or grandparents are present in 69.2% of the occurrences.

     The most common toxic agents were insecticides (46.6%), hydrocarbons in (24.1%), corrosives in (19.8%), and medicinal agents in (9.5%). There were statistically insignificant differences between studied groups. These results were comparable to those reported by Hassan and Siam (2014) who reported that pesticides are the most common agent implicated in their poisoned children. The increased prevalence of insecticide toxicity can be explained by the fact that, Damietta governorate (especially new Damietta area) is one of the major agricultural areas in Egypt, and the easy access, inappropriate handling and usage of insecticides are common. In developing countries, where the economy is based on agriculture, in addition to poisoning by medications, cases involving other agents such as insecticides and venomous animals are frequent (Mendonca et al., 2016). In a study conducted in India, Chowdhury et al. (2008) verified that pesticides, mainly organophosphates, were the most frequent agents involved (53.3%), followed by chemical household products (33.7%), mainly kerosene (24%). On the other hand, Oprescu et al. (2012) reported that the most common poisoning substances in this study were prescription and over-the-counter medication, alcohol, chemical products (i.e. household, automotive, and farm chemicals), and carbon monoxide. These results indicate the different epidemiology between different regions.

     In the present work, poisoning by medication is the last category; and these results were in contradiction to those reported by other studies held in developing countries such as Serilanka (Fernando, 2002), Nepal (Khadka, 2005), and Ethiopia (Ozdogan et al., 2008), but in agreement with studies in Taiwan (Lee et al., 2008), other Asian countries, some western countries, and Turkey (Mutlu et al., 2010).

     In the present work, hydrocarbons were reported in 24.1%. This were higher than that reported by Hassan and Siam (2014) who reported that, petroleum products were attributed to 13% of the cases of poisoning which was in agreement with other studies held in developing countries (Akhtar et al., 2006). In addition, Aggarwal et al. (2014) reported that hydrocarbons, insecticides and drugs were the most commonly identified agents of poisoning in their study. Among hydrocarbons, kerosene poising was most common. Kerosene ingestion was also noted to be the commonest cause of accidental poisoning in our study. This was observed in age category less than 6 years due to its mistaken identity as water when kept in soft drink bottles as is usually stored in rural area. All cases of kerosene poisoning in this study were successfully discharged without complications. Other studies have reported kerosene as a common poisoning agent (Kohli et al., 2008 and Venkatesh et al., 2011)

     30.2% of children were discharged after hospital admission and 69.8% were discharged from Emergency Department; with a statistically significant difference between studied groups. The discharge rate from Emergency Department decreased with increasing age.  These results were in agreement with Hon and Leung (2010) who reported that most childhood poisoning cases are trivial and many do not require medical care. In addition, results of the present study were in agreement with Litovitz et al. (2005) who reported that only 10% of poison exposures in children younger than 6 years that were reported to poison centers were ultimately managed in health care facilities (HCFs). They added that, health care facility use is slightly higher in 6- to 12-year-old children (13% of cases are managed in HCFs) and substantially higher in teens (48%). The greater use of HCFs in teenage poison exposures is directly attributable to the large contribution of intentional poison exposure cases (46%) where, because of the intent as well as the greater severity, physician evaluation is more often required.

CONCLUSION

     The present study provided a road map for the pattern of childhood toxicity in Damietta governorate. It is the first step to explore the magnitude of the problem in this area of Egypt. Future efforts are needed to complete the map with development of effective preventive strategies.

REFERENCES

1. Aggarwal B, Rana SK and Chhavi N. (2014): Pattern of Poisoning in Children, an Experience From a Teaching Hospital in Northern India. JK Science, 16(4): 174-178.

2. Agran PF, Winn D, Anderson C, Trent R and Walton-Haynes L. (2001): Rates of pediatric and adolescent injuries by year of age. Pediatrics, 108 (3): E45.

3. Akhtar S, Raj RG and Al-Anezi F. (2006): Risk factors in acute poisoning in children: a retrospective study. Kuwait Medical Journal, 38:33–36.

4. Andiran N and Sarikayalar F. (2004): Pattern of acute poisoning in childhood in Ankara: what has change in twenty years? Turkish J Pediatr., 46 (2): 147–152.

5. Azkunaga B, Mintegi S, Salmón N, Acedo Y and Del Arco L. (2013): Poisoning in children under age 7 in Spain. Areas of improvement in the prevention and treatment. An Pediatr (Barc)., 78:355-360.

6. Bentur Y, Obchinikov ND, Cahana A, Kovler NBloom-Krasik ALavon OGurevych B and Lurie Y. (2010): Pediatric poisonings in Israel: National Poison Center Data. Isr Med Assoc J., 12:554-559.

7. Bicer S, Sezer S, Xetindag F and Kesikminare M (2007): Evaluation of acute intoxications in pediatric emergency clinic in 2005. Marmara Med J., 20 (1): 12–20.

8. Chowdhury NA, Banerjee S, Brahma A and Biswas MK. (2008): A study on mortality and morbidity pattern of acute childhood poisoning cases admitted in block primary health centers of Sundarban, West Bengal. Indian J Public Health, 52:40-42.

9. Fernando R. (2002): The national poison information center in Sri Lanka: the first ten years. Journal of Toxicology-Clinical Toxicology, 40 (5): 551–555.

10. Hassan BA and Siam MG. (2014): Patterns of Acute Poisoning in Childhood in Zagazig, Egypt: An Epidemiological Study. Hindawi Publishing Corporation International Scholarly Research Notices; Volume 2014, Article ID 245279, 5 pages.

11. Hon KL, Ho JK, Leung TF, Wong Y, Nelson EA and Fok TF. (2005): Review of children hospitalized for ingestion and poisoning at a tertiary center. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, 34 (5): 356–361.

12. Hon, KL and Leung AK. (2010): Childhood Accidents: Injuries and Poisoning. Advances in Pediatrics, 57: 33–62.

13. Khadka SB. (2005): A study of poisoning in Emergency Kathmandu medical college teaching hospital. Kathmandu University Medical Journal, 3(4): 388–391.

14. Kivisto JE, Arvola T, Parkkari J and Mattila VM. (2008-a): Pediatric poisonings treated in one Finnish main university hospital between 2002 and 2006. Acta Paediatr., 97: 790–4.

15. Kivistö JE, Mattila VM, Arvola T, Paavola M and Parkkari J. (2008-b): Secular trends in poisonings leading to hospital admission among Finnish children and adolescents between 1971 and 2005. J Pediatr., 153: 820-824.

16. Kohli U, Kuttiat VS, Lodha R and Kabra SK. (2008): Profile of childhood poisoning at a tertiary care centre in North India. Indian J Pediatr., 75: 791-4.

17. Lamireau T, Llanas B, Kennedy A, Fayon M, Penouil F, Favarell-Garrigues JC and Demarquez JL. (2002): Epidemiology of poisoning in children: a 7-year survey in a pediatric emergency care unit. Eur J Emergency Med., 9 (1): 9–14.

18. Lee HL, Lin HJ, Yeh SW, Chi CH and Guo HR. (2008): Etiology and outcome of patients presenting for poisoning to the emergency department in Taiwan: a prospective study. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 27 (5): 373–379.

19. Lin LJ, Shih TJ and Tsai JL. (2003): The patients presented in ED with poisoning exposure, 1995–2002. Taiwan Society of Emergency Medicine, 5:181–189.

20. Litovitz T, White NC and Watson WA. (2005): Epidemiology of Pediatric Poison Exposures: An Analysis of 2003 Poison Control Center Data. Clin Ped Emerg Med., 6:68-75.

 

21. Lourenco J, Furtado BMA and Bonfim C. (2008): Intoxicações exógenas em crianças atendidas em uma unidade de emergência pediátrica. Acta Paulista de Enfermagem, 21: 282-286. (English abstract).

22. Mendonca DR, Menezes MS, Matos MA and Santos D. (2016): Acute Poisoning in Children in Bahia, Brazil. Global Pediatric Health, 3: 1–7.

23. Mutlu M, Cansu A, Karakas T, Kalyoncu M and Erduran E. (2010): Pattern of pediatric poisoning in the east Karadeniz region between 2002 and 2006: increased suicide poisoning. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 29 (2): 131–136.

24. O’Connor PJ. (2005): Differentials in poisoning rates of young Australian children according to residential location and geographical remoteness.  Injury Prevention, 11 (4): 204–206.

25. Oprescu F, Peek-Asa C, Wallis A, Young T, Nour D and Cherecheş RM. (2012): Pediatric Poisonings and Risk Markers for Hospital Admission in a Major Emergency Department in Romania. Matern Child Health J., 16:495–500.

26. Ozdogan H, Davutoglu M, Bosnak M, Tutanc M and Haspolat K. (2008): Pediatric poisonings in southeast of Turkey: epidemiological and clinical aspects. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 27 (1):  45–48.

27. Peden M., Oyegbite K., Ozanne-Smith J , Hyder A, Branche C, Rahman AKM, Rivara F, and Bartolomeos K (2008): World Report on Child Injury Prevention, WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.

28. Rajapakse T, Griffiths KM and Christensen H. (2013): Characteristics of non-fatal self-poisoning in Sri Lanka: a systematic review. BMC Public Health, 13: 331.

29. Rajka T, Heyerdahl F, Hovda KE, Stiksrud B and Jacobsen D. (2007): Acute child poisonings in Oslo: a 2-year prospective study. Acta Paediatrica., 96: 1355–1359.

30. Riordan M, Rylance G and Berry K. (2002): Poisoning in children 1: general management. Arch Dis Childhood., 87(5):392–6.

31. Rodgers Jr GC, Condurache T, Reed MD, Bestic M and Gal P. (2007):  Poisonings. In: Nelson’s Textbook of Pediatrics, R. M. Kliegman, R. E. Behrman, H. B. Jenson, and B. F. Stanton, Eds., pp. 689–732, pbl. Saunders: Elsevier, New York, NY, USA.

32. Singh SP, Aggarwal AD, Oberoi SS, Aggarwal K. K., Abhininder S. Thind, Diwan S. Bhullar, D Walia S, Preetinder and Chahal S. (2013): Study of poisoning trends in north India--a perspective in relation to world statistics. J Forensic Leg Med., 20: 14-8.

33. Siqueira HM, Brandão JR and Brasileiro MSE. (2008): Perfil das intoxicações exógenas infantis atendidas em um hospital especializado da rede pública de Goiânia-GO. Rev Eletr Enf., 10: 662-672. (English abstract).

34. Tavares OE, Buriola AA and Oliveira MLF. (2013): Fatores associados à intoxicação infantil. Escola Anna Nery., 17:31-37 (English abstract).

35. Torgerson PR, Devleesschauwer B, Praet N, Torgerson PR, Devleesschauwer B, Praet N, Speybroeck N, Willingham AL, Kasuga F, Rokni MB, Zhou XN, Fèvre EM, Sripa B, Gargouri N, Fürst T, Budke CM, Carabin H, Kirk MD, Angulo FJ, Havelaar A and de Silva N. (2015): World Health Organization Estimates of the Global and Regional Disease Burden of 11 Foodborne Parasitic Diseases, 2010: A Data Synthesis. PLoS Med., 12(12):e1001920.

36. Venkatesh C, Sriram P and Mahadevan S. (2011): Clinical profile of children with kerosene aspiration. Trop Doct., 41: 179-80.


تقییم التسمم الحاد بین الأطفال بمحافظة دمیاط

 

أحمد إبراهیم الشوری، مجدی محمد شریف*، توفیق محمد نور الدین**،

مکی عبد المنعم علی***، محمد على عبود****، مصطفی عبدالمنعم غانم*

 

أقسام الطب الشرعی والسموم الإکلینیکیة*،التخدیر والرعایة المرکزة**، الباثولوجیا الإکلینیکیة***،

والأشعة التشخیصیة**** کلیة طب الأزهر

 

خلفیة البحث: التسمم غیر المتعمد یمثل مشکلة صحیة هامة فى الأطفال. وبالرغم من ذلک لا توجد خریطة مناسبة تساعد فى تصمیم الإستراتیجیات الوقائیة المناسبة.  

الهدف من البحث: صممت الدراسة الحالیة بهدف فحص نمط التسمم الحاد لدی الأطفال فی المجموعة العمریة من 1 – 18 عاما بمحافظة دمیاط.

الأشخاص وطرق البحث: شملت الدراسة الأطفال المترددین على قسم الطوارئ فی مرکز مراقبة السموم بدمیاط  خلال الفترة من ینایر 2015 إلى دیسمبر 2015. وفی جمیع الأطفال، تمت دراسة المعاییر التالیة: متوسط العمر، الجنس، الإقامة، الوظیفة ان وجدت ، طریقة التعرض، کیفیة التسمم، الوقت المنقضی بین التعرض للسموم والوصول للمستشفى، التاریخ الطبی السابق، التاریخ العائلی، التوزیع الموسمی، ومکان الحجز (قسم الطوارئ، القسم الداخلى، وحدة العنایة المرکزة، أو الإحالة) وکذلک مصیرها (التحسن، الإحالة أوالموت). وشمل الفحص السریری والمعملى الفحص العام، الفحص المنتظم والفحوصات (الفحوصات المعملیة، تخطیط القلب، الأشعة السینیة العادیة على الصدر، الأشعة السینیة العادیة على البطن، والأشعة المقطعیة و / أو أشعة الرنین المغناطیسی فی حالات الغیبوبة أو غیر المبررة). شمل الجانب العلاجی لهذه الدراسة ما یلی: تدابیر الطوارئ، إزالة التلوث، تعزیز التخلص من السموم وإعطاء علاج محدد).

النتائج: أسفرت نتائج الدراسة عن وجود فروق دالة إحصائیا بین مجموعات الدراسة طبقا لمتغیر النوع . وکان قاطنی الریف (78.4%)، قاطنی المدن(21.6%). وکانت أکثر المواد تناولا هی المبیدات الحشریة (46.6%)، الهیدروکربونات بنسبة (24.1%)،المواد الحارقه (19.8%) والمواد الدوائیة (9.5%). وکان التسمم من النوع البسیط لدی أغلبیة الأطفال (72.4%) ووجد أن شدة التسمم تتناسب طردیا مع عمر الطفل، وکان زمن التأخر أقل من ساعة فی معظم الاطفال (58.6%). وتناول المادة السامة عن طریق الفم کان الأکثر شیوعا( 69%)، والتسمم عن طریق الفم یزید بتقدم العمر. وکان التسمم حادث عرضی فی معظم أطفال الدراسة(84.5%) ولم توجد حالات انتحاریة فی العمر أقل من 6 سنوات. وکان المنزل هو مسرح التسمم لدی غالبیة اطفال الدراسة (84.5%)، وخارج المنزل (15.5%)، مع وجود فروق دالة احصائیا بینهم. وتم حجز( 30.2%) من الأطفال بالقسم الداخلی، وصرف (69.8%) من قسم الطواریء إلی المنزل مباشرة. وقد وجد أن معدل علاج الحالات بالقسم الداخلی یتناسب طردیا مع عمر الأطفال.

الإستنتاج: قدمت الدراسة الحالیة خارطة طریق لنمط التسمم لدی الأطفال بمحافظة دمیاط. وهذه أول خطوة لبیان حجم المشکلة فی هذه المنطقة من مصر. ونحن فی حاجة إلی جهود مستقبلیة لتکملة هذه الخارطة وتطویر الإستراتیجیات الوقائیة.     

 

REFERENCES
1. Aggarwal B, Rana SK and Chhavi N. (2014): Pattern of Poisoning in Children, an Experience From a Teaching Hospital in Northern India. JK Science, 16(4): 174-178.
2. Agran PF, Winn D, Anderson C, Trent R and Walton-Haynes L. (2001): Rates of pediatric and adolescent injuries by year of age. Pediatrics, 108 (3): E45.
3. Akhtar S, Raj RG and Al-Anezi F. (2006): Risk factors in acute poisoning in children: a retrospective study. Kuwait Medical Journal, 38:33–36.
4. Andiran N and Sarikayalar F. (2004): Pattern of acute poisoning in childhood in Ankara: what has change in twenty years? Turkish J Pediatr., 46 (2): 147–152.
5. Azkunaga B, Mintegi S, Salmón N, Acedo Y and Del Arco L. (2013): Poisoning in children under age 7 in Spain. Areas of improvement in the prevention and treatment. An Pediatr (Barc)., 78:355-360.
6. Bentur Y, Obchinikov ND, Cahana A, Kovler NBloom-Krasik ALavon OGurevych B and Lurie Y. (2010): Pediatric poisonings in Israel: National Poison Center Data. Isr Med Assoc J., 12:554-559.
7. Bicer S, Sezer S, Xetindag F and Kesikminare M (2007): Evaluation of acute intoxications in pediatric emergency clinic in 2005. Marmara Med J., 20 (1): 12–20.
8. Chowdhury NA, Banerjee S, Brahma A and Biswas MK. (2008): A study on mortality and morbidity pattern of acute childhood poisoning cases admitted in block primary health centers of Sundarban, West Bengal. Indian J Public Health, 52:40-42.
9. Fernando R. (2002): The national poison information center in Sri Lanka: the first ten years. Journal of Toxicology-Clinical Toxicology, 40 (5): 551–555.
10. Hassan BA and Siam MG. (2014): Patterns of Acute Poisoning in Childhood in Zagazig, Egypt: An Epidemiological Study. Hindawi Publishing Corporation International Scholarly Research Notices; Volume 2014, Article ID 245279, 5 pages.
11. Hon KL, Ho JK, Leung TF, Wong Y, Nelson EA and Fok TF. (2005): Review of children hospitalized for ingestion and poisoning at a tertiary center. Annals of the Academy of Medicine, 34 (5): 356–361.
12. Hon, KL and Leung AK. (2010): Childhood Accidents: Injuries and Poisoning. Advances in Pediatrics, 57: 33–62.
13. Khadka SB. (2005): A study of poisoning in Emergency Kathmandu medical college teaching hospital. Kathmandu University Medical Journal, 3(4): 388–391.
14. Kivisto JE, Arvola T, Parkkari J and Mattila VM. (2008-a): Pediatric poisonings treated in one Finnish main university hospital between 2002 and 2006. Acta Paediatr., 97: 790–4.
15. Kivistö JE, Mattila VM, Arvola T, Paavola M and Parkkari J. (2008-b): Secular trends in poisonings leading to hospital admission among Finnish children and adolescents between 1971 and 2005. J Pediatr., 153: 820-824.
16. Kohli U, Kuttiat VS, Lodha R and Kabra SK. (2008): Profile of childhood poisoning at a tertiary care centre in North India. Indian J Pediatr., 75: 791-4.
17. Lamireau T, Llanas B, Kennedy A, Fayon M, Penouil F, Favarell-Garrigues JC and Demarquez JL. (2002): Epidemiology of poisoning in children: a 7-year survey in a pediatric emergency care unit. Eur J Emergency Med., 9 (1): 9–14.
18. Lee HL, Lin HJ, Yeh SW, Chi CH and Guo HR. (2008): Etiology and outcome of patients presenting for poisoning to the emergency department in Taiwan: a prospective study. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 27 (5): 373–379.
19. Lin LJ, Shih TJ and Tsai JL. (2003): The patients presented in ED with poisoning exposure, 1995–2002. Taiwan Society of Emergency Medicine, 5:181–189.
20. Litovitz T, White NC and Watson WA. (2005): Epidemiology of Pediatric Poison Exposures: An Analysis of 2003 Poison Control Center Data. Clin Ped Emerg Med., 6:68-75.
 
21. Lourenco J, Furtado BMA and Bonfim C. (2008): Intoxicações exógenas em crianças atendidas em uma unidade de emergência pediátrica. Acta Paulista de Enfermagem, 21: 282-286. (English abstract).
22. Mendonca DR, Menezes MS, Matos MA and Santos D. (2016): Acute Poisoning in Children in Bahia, Brazil. Global Pediatric Health, 3: 1–7.
23. Mutlu M, Cansu A, Karakas T, Kalyoncu M and Erduran E. (2010): Pattern of pediatric poisoning in the east Karadeniz region between 2002 and 2006: increased suicide poisoning. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 29 (2): 131–136.
24. O’Connor PJ. (2005): Differentials in poisoning rates of young Australian children according to residential location and geographical remoteness.  Injury Prevention, 11 (4): 204–206.
25. Oprescu F, Peek-Asa C, Wallis A, Young T, Nour D and Cherecheş RM. (2012): Pediatric Poisonings and Risk Markers for Hospital Admission in a Major Emergency Department in Romania. Matern Child Health J., 16:495–500.
26. Ozdogan H, Davutoglu M, Bosnak M, Tutanc M and Haspolat K. (2008): Pediatric poisonings in southeast of Turkey: epidemiological and clinical aspects. Human and Experimental Toxicology, 27 (1):  45–48.
27. Peden M., Oyegbite K., Ozanne-Smith J , Hyder A, Branche C, Rahman AKM, Rivara F, and Bartolomeos K (2008): World Report on Child Injury Prevention, WHO, Geneva, Switzerland.
28. Rajapakse T, Griffiths KM and Christensen H. (2013): Characteristics of non-fatal self-poisoning in Sri Lanka: a systematic review. BMC Public Health, 13: 331.
29. Rajka T, Heyerdahl F, Hovda KE, Stiksrud B and Jacobsen D. (2007): Acute child poisonings in Oslo: a 2-year prospective study. Acta Paediatrica., 96: 1355–1359.
30. Riordan M, Rylance G and Berry K. (2002): Poisoning in children 1: general management. Arch Dis Childhood., 87(5):392–6.
31. Rodgers Jr GC, Condurache T, Reed MD, Bestic M and Gal P. (2007):  Poisonings. In: Nelson’s Textbook of Pediatrics, R. M. Kliegman, R. E. Behrman, H. B. Jenson, and B. F. Stanton, Eds., pp. 689–732, pbl. Saunders: Elsevier, New York, NY, USA.
32. Singh SP, Aggarwal AD, Oberoi SS, Aggarwal K. K., Abhininder S. Thind, Diwan S. Bhullar, D Walia S, Preetinder and Chahal S. (2013): Study of poisoning trends in north India--a perspective in relation to world statistics. J Forensic Leg Med., 20: 14-8.
33. Siqueira HM, Brandão JR and Brasileiro MSE. (2008): Perfil das intoxicações exógenas infantis atendidas em um hospital especializado da rede pública de Goiânia-GO. Rev Eletr Enf., 10: 662-672. (English abstract).
34. Tavares OE, Buriola AA and Oliveira MLF. (2013): Fatores associados à intoxicação infantil. Escola Anna Nery., 17:31-37 (English abstract).
35. Torgerson PR, Devleesschauwer B, Praet N, Torgerson PR, Devleesschauwer B, Praet N, Speybroeck N, Willingham AL, Kasuga F, Rokni MB, Zhou XN, Fèvre EM, Sripa B, Gargouri N, Fürst T, Budke CM, Carabin H, Kirk MD, Angulo FJ, Havelaar A and de Silva N. (2015): World Health Organization Estimates of the Global and Regional Disease Burden of 11 Foodborne Parasitic Diseases, 2010: A Data Synthesis. PLoS Med., 12(12):e1001920.
36. Venkatesh C, Sriram P and Mahadevan S. (2011): Clinical profile of children with kerosene aspiration. Trop Doct., 41: 179-80.